Subject: Side effects and large-scale conversion From: Sam Hunting <sgmlsh@xxxxxxx> Date: Tue, 23 Sep 1997 10:27:19 -0400 (EDT) |
Consider the following quotation: <extract source=anonymous> This sounds like the whole "no-side-effect" religion embraced by DSSSL that makes it nearly useless to me in a large conversion project. For large sets of conversion operations which are linearly tied by complex dependencies, and for other practical software engineering needs, side effects are necessary. As with goto's, any mechanism can be abused, but that doesn't mean we should never use them (heck, all C++ exceptions are just glorified goto's). A recursive decent scoped model for software engineering is certainly the way to go, *BUT* too many people equate this with no side effects allowed. </extract> My programming expertise is insufficient to judge the validity of the statement above. Has anyone ever used DSSSL for large-scale conversion (1000s of pages) -- doubtful -- and if so, did the prohibition of side effects get in the way? Why or why not? Why was the "no side effects" design decision made? Do I misunderstand that such a decision was made? If it has been made, is it a significant bar to doing "real programming" with DSSSL? Or is it that DSSSL is solely for specification, and the programming is done elsewhere? (After all, if one thinks of a specification as a contract, clearly contracts don't have side effects -- things not specified in the contract -- because otherwise the parties signing the contract wouldn't be acting with equivalent knowledge.) If so, where does one draw the line, especially given that DSSSL is extensible? Signed, Puzzled (Sam Hunting) DSSSList info and archive: http://www.mulberrytech.com/dsssl/dssslist
Current Thread |
---|
|
<- Previous | Index | Next -> |
---|---|---|
Re: Jade & Tables & RTF questions.., James Clark | Thread | Re: Side effects and large-scale co, Vivek Agrawala |
Jade & Tables & RTF questions..., Oisin McGuinness | Date | Re: Side effects and large-scale co, Vivek Agrawala |
Month |