Subject: Re: [jats-list] Tagging user facility support - ORCID Working Group question From: "Tommie Usdin btusdin@xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx" <jats-list-service@xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx> Date: Wed, 2 Aug 2017 11:53:14 -0000 |
Hi Mark b I think <award-group award-type="facility-supportb> is the much more robust approach. Not that the other would not work, but it opens the door to an unlimited number of additional special-purpose tags. Not long ago I had a conversation with someone trying to figure out how, in JATS, to acknowledge a gift of free access to a set of commercial data sets - not quite the same as providing facilities, but not quite a grant of money. We didnbt think of using <funding-group> with a descriptive @award-type, but now that I see your example I will pass it on. This seems like a clear, flexible, and extensible approach. b Tommie > On Aug 1, 2017, at 5:28 PM, Mark Doyle doyle@xxxxxxx <jats-list-service@xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx> wrote: > > Dear all, > > I am part of an ORCID working group that is working with publishers and US Department of Agency national labs that provide researchers with access to user facilities run by the DOE. The goal is to try and better track the publications that result from research conducted at these facilities. You can learn more about this effort at https://orcid.org/about/community <https://orcid.org/about/community>. One of the questions that has arisen in our discussions is how might we best accomplish the tagging of this type of support, which is distinct from direct monetary funding. Before submitting a request for a change in JATS, the group has asked me to consult here. > > The main concern is whether user facility usage, which does have to go through a request/approval process and gets an award number, should be considered semantically the same as "funding." Also, I have explicitly cc'ed Chuck from Crossref because we also have concerns about how this might work when publishers deposit metadata using JATS. > > 1) So one option is to simply use <funding-group> and include an agreed upon new value for the award-type attribute on <award-group>, something like: > > <funding-group> > <award-group award-type="grant"> > <funding-source country="US">National Science Foundation</funding-source> > <award-id>NSF DBI-0317510</award-id> > </award-group> > <award-group award-type="facility-support"> > <funding-source country="US">Spallation Neutron Source</funding-source> > <award-id>SPS 12345</award-id> > </award-group> > </funding-group> > > This solution doesn't require a change to JATS, but may require additional facilities added to the Crossref Open Funder Registry. > > 2) Another solution would be to introduce a new container element and new tags that are more specific to research facilities and non-monetary group to avoid the semantic confusion over the term "funding". For example, new (not fully thought out) tags could be <research-facility-group>, <user-facility>, and/or <facility-award>, etc. > > This has the advantage of strongly identifying the semantics of the information and perhaps could be made general enough to support other kinds of non-monetary support. This would of course require new tags to be introduced into JATS. > > 3) Another possibility that was discussed was to somehow incorporate this information using affiliation tagging, but the working group consensus was that this wasn't a good approach. > > It would be helpful to have some feedback on options 1 and 2 (or other suggestions!) so that the working group could make a strong recommendation, if needed, to the JATS Standing Committee. > > Thanks for considering. > > Best regards, > Mark > > Mark Doyle > Chief Information Officer > American Physical Society > > > > JATS-List info and archive <http://www.mulberrytech.com/JATS/JATS-List/> > EasyUnsubscribe <-list/1840> (by email <>)
Current Thread |
---|
|
<- Previous | Index | Next -> |
---|---|---|
[jats-list] Tagging user facility s, Mark Doyle doyle@xxx | Thread | [jats-list] JATS-List Guidelines, B Tommie Usdin btusd |
[jats-list] Tagging user facility s, Mark Doyle doyle@xxx | Date | [jats-list] JATS-List Guidelines, B Tommie Usdin btusd |
Month |