RE: [xsl] Need 3 good reasons why XSLT is better than JSP+Velocit y

["Kovach, Dave" <dave.kovach@xxxxxxx>]

1. A group could build their own Velocity/framework or templating system
using XSLT that is more specific to their project or application.

2. Rid of JSP's altogether and use XSLT/XHTML bolted to a Servlet engine
running with Saxon (or another XSLT engine) - JSP's can be discarded (dont
have to be, but could be)

3. XSLT works non-procedurally and does its magic recursively. This is the
win. Much data that is trapped in DBMS's doesn't need to be - so many things
we put there are hierarchical by nature not relational and XSLT is suited
like NO OTHER to handle and present this info in various ways (VIEWS) to
various devices - all by changing some XSLT code in an XSL stylesheet. How,
it works through XML data or properly structured info can not be replicated
anywhere - not via a Velocity structure or anything.

(sounds like the typical, developers holding tightly onto what
they know and how they already do things - is good enough. But,
XSLT was built for XML... JSP and Servlets (much less Velocity)
were not)


David Kovach
SAP Labs
Palo Alto, CA

-----Original Message-----
From: Wes Lagrone [mailto:WLagrone@xxxxxxxxxxxxx]
Sent: Wednesday, January 30, 2002 5:21 AM
To: XSL-List@xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx
Subject: [xsl] Need 3 good reasons why XSLT is better than JSP+Velocity


Wondering if anyone could shed light on a debate I've been having with
web developers.

If the source content for my web site is a stack of XML files, XSLT
seems like the obvious choice to assemble, format and generate the
output XHTML pages.

But many web developers tell me that they'd rather use Velocity
templates in conjunction with JSP to accomplish the same thing, whether
the source content comes from flat XML files, an XML repository, or an
Oracle database.  They know Java, they argue, so why bother with XSLT? 

So I'm looking for three good reasons why they're wrong.
 
Thanks,

Wes 

 XSL-List info and archive:  http://www.mulberrytech.com/xsl/xsl-list

 XSL-List info and archive:  http://www.mulberrytech.com/xsl/xsl-list