Re: [xsl] XSLT Hello World

Subject: Re: [xsl] XSLT Hello World
From: Ihe Onwuka <ihe.onwuka@xxxxxxxxx>
Date: Mon, 24 Mar 2014 16:53:50 +0000
Just want to make sure this is absolutely clear because I think this
might blur the message I was trying to convey.

What Wendell has quoted is what I would do if my objective was to do a
hatchet job on XSLT to people not familiar with it. It's part of a
languages PR that the small subset of the language that is exercised
most frequently doesn't contain surprises. If it does it will either
turn people away from your language (price of admission too high for
them)  and/or those with an antagonistic agenda to the language will
leverage that to achieve their aim.

People also try to disparage Java and portray it as verbose and
cumbersome by showing how much palaver it is to write Hello World

e.g from

class HelloWorldApp {
    public static void main(String[] args) {
        System.out.println("Hello World!");

... with Ruby's:

puts 'Hello World!'

unfortunately they were unsuccessful.

On Mon, Mar 24, 2014 at 4:05 PM, Wendell Piez <wapiez@xxxxxxxxxxxxxxx> wrote:
> Hi,
> Over in that other thread, Ihe said:
>> Extracting text from an XML document is the hello world of XSLT.
>> text() would appear to be an obvious way of doing that and it's really
>> important that it entails no surprises. If I were an XSLT antagonist
>> that is exactly the sort of thing I would  home in on to portray the
>> language as arcane, difficult to use and not suitable for my project.
> I find this really quite interesting.
> One thing I stress to beginners is that if they're starting to learn
> the language using only a syntax reference plus whatever they might
> know about Perl, Python or Java, they are heading for a world of hurt.
> It's not like your granddaddy's programming language, and when you
> assume things like "text() is the way to get my data into the output,
> because it says 'text'" ... ouch.
> Indeed, the Hello World I like to use looks like this:
> <xsl:stylesheet version="2.0"
>   xmlns:xsl="";>
> </xsl:stylesheet>
> I.e., a stylesheet with no templates at all. (You can also write it as
> an empty element if you prefer.)
> After having acknowledged our astonishment at the results of running
> this, we can talk about the built-in templates. And then we start
> writing templates of our own ... matching elements, not text nodes. We
> do this with a source document with mixed content (such as <doc>Hello
> <who>World</who></doc> ), (so we can try a few things out such as
> matching elements in line), and then a slightly more elaborate
> instance (perhaps including some comments or processing instructions
> so we can illustrate aspects of the data model, such as text nodes) .
> Take in a few points of fact, practice for an hour or two, and get a
> good night's sleep, and you no longer run the risk that you will be
> surprised by 'text()' in XSLT.
> Talking about the processing model in the context of documents with
> mixed content also gives us an early opportunity to start thinking
> about XSLT's purposes, strengths and weaknesses.
> I know this approach may reinforce the impressions of some programmers
> that XSLT is, as Ihe says, "arcane, difficult to use and not suitable
> for my project". To this my only answer is in the doing of it.
> Assuming your problem is in fact in XSLT's sweet spot, showing how
> powerful and easy XSLT is ... once you have a clue ... answers the
> critique by itself.
> If your problem isn't in XSLT's sweet spot, I ask why are you
> interested in it. Yes, XSLT is generally very powerful, and can be
> used for problems often quite different from the kinds of document
> processing for which it was designed. But please please don't expect
> an easy time trying to tackle one of those in XSLT before you have a
> feel for templates and traversals.
> The thing about "arcane" is also relative. Indeed, if you aren't
> naturally a curious sort with a reasonable tolerance for the arcane,
> one wonders why you expect to do well with programming at all.
> Cheers, Wendell
> --
> Wendell Piez |
> XML | XSLT | electronic publishing
> Eat Your Vegetables
> _____oo_________o_o___ooooo____ooooooo_^

Current Thread