Subject: RE: Fair use question From: "Blobaum, Paul" <p-blobaum@xxxxxxxxx> Date: Tue, 20 Apr 2004 12:32:18 -0500 |
The educational guideline of 3 minutes only applies to educational *multimedia* projects, in face to face educational uses to enrolled students in accredited non profit (non commercial) educational institutions. Since he is wanting to publish a transcript in a book, I just don't see a case for using "fair use". Besides these are only guidelines endorsed by certain publishers, not necessarily PBS or whoever made that documentary. The editor of the book would certainly require permission to use a transcript. When in doubt, *ask permission*. Paul Paul Blobaum 708-534-4990 x5142 University Professor and Health Sciences Librarian Governors State University Library University Park, IL 60466 p-blobaum@xxxxxxxxx -----Original Message----- From: Laura Pope-Robbins [mailto:Pope-Rol@xxxxxxxxxxx] Sent: Tuesday, April 20, 2004 11:38 AM To: digital-copyright@xxxxxxxxxxxxxx Subject: Fair use question I've been lurking on this list for awhile, and now I find I need some guidance. An individual has asked me to look into whether his potential use of a video would be considered fair use. I think it would, but I cannot find any instances of similar uses to the one he describes in any articles. He is writing a book and is thinking about incorporating 7 minutes of a video, which he would transcribe as a question and answer portion. The video itself is one 60-minute episode of a 4-part series broadcast by PBS. I realize that 7 minutes goes beyond the 3 minutes recommended in the multimedia guidelines, but he is writing a book, not creating a multimedia project. I also realize that 7 minutes goes beyond the general 10% guideline, but that in and of itself does not negate fair use. In researching this topic, the closest instance I found was the Seinfeld trivia book, which made much broader use of the Seinfeld episodes than he is considering in this case. We've gone over the fair use guidelines carefully, which is why I think his use would be fair, and I've recommended that it never hurts to seek permission, but . . . What are your reactions? Would you consider this fair use? Does anyone know of a similar situation and how it was resolved? Thank you. Laura Pope Robbins Assistant Professor/Reference Librarian Dowling College / Library 150 Idle Hour Boulevard Oakdale, NY 11769 Phone: (631) 244-5023 Fax: (631) 244- 3374 E-mail: pope-rol@xxxxxxxxxxx "A book is the only place in which you can examine a fragile thought without breaking it or, explore an explosive idea without fear it will go off in your face . . . It is one of the few havens remaining where a man's mind can get both provocation and privacy." -- Edward P. Morgan --------------------------------------------------------------------- You are subscribed as: p-blobaum@xxxxxxxxx To unsubscribe, go to: http://lists.umuc.edu/unsub.php/digital-copyright/p-blobaum@xxxxxxxxx or e-mail: <mailto:digital-copyright-unsubscribe-p-blobaum=govst.edu@xxxxxxxxxxxxxx >
Current Thread |
---|
|
<- Previous | Index | Next -> |
---|---|---|
Fair use question, Laura Pope-Robbins | Thread | RE: Fair use question OOops, Blobaum, Paul |
Fair use question, Laura Pope-Robbins | Date | RE: Fair use question OOops, Blobaum, Paul |
Month |