Re: [xsl] For CSV output file - should end of record marker be line feed or a carriage return from xsl

Subject: Re: [xsl] For CSV output file - should end of record marker be line feed or a carriage return from xsl
From: "Paul Tyson phtyson@xxxxxxxxxxxxx" <xsl-list-service@xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx>
Date: Sat, 8 Nov 2014 13:11:34 -0000
RFC 4180 standardizes CRLF as the record separator for mime type "text/csv".
So to that end the safest platform-independent way to specify compliant output
is to write "&#13;&#10;" or equivalent in your stylesheet.

However if you don't need compliant "text/csv" output then any other suggested
method will work.


> On Nov 7, 2014, at 18:10, Richard Fozzard - NOAA Affiliate
richard.fozzard@xxxxxxxx <xsl-list-service@xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx> wrote:
> Wolfgang Laun wolfgang.laun@xxxxxxxxx wrote on 11/07/2014 02:06 PM:
>> You'll stand a better chance of getting your line ends right by using
>> <xsl:text>
>> </xsl:text>
>> with the line end being represented by whatever it is on the system where
>> the text file containing these two lines resides.
> Agreed! If your XSLT is running on the same OS where you plan to use the
>> (This would be CR+LF on
>> Windowses, LF on Unices and CR on Mac OSs.)
> BTW, the CR was only used on Mac OS 9 and earlier:
> Mac OS 10.* shifted to Unix (FreeBSD) back in about 2001.
> XML/XSL (and HTML) were designed from the ground up to handle just about any
kind of end-of-line you wanted to throw at them. But of course, the program
using your CSV may not be so tolerant. It sounds like you're using Windows,
and some of those older Windows programs may require the traditional CR+LF.
> --Rich
>> Explicitly requesting CR or LF or CR+LF means that the result will not
>> necessarily have the intended line structure on one system or the other,
>> i.e., wherever you run the XSLT.
>> -W
>> On 7 November 2014 18:40, Catherine Wilbur cwilbur@xxxxxxxxxxx <
>> xsl-list-service@xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx> wrote:
>>> 1) Currently I am using a line feed in my code at the end.  Should it be
>>> line feed or carriage return?  Reason I am asking is because when I open
>>> CSV file in NotePad or WordPad the data wraps.  But with Notes++ or Excel
>>> the data does not wrap.  Currently using a line feed at end of my data.
>>> Assuming it should be a carriage return.  Guessing that the data is
>>> wrapping when I open the CSV file because it does not recognize the
>>> carriage return or line feed but Notes++ does recognize these characters.
>>> Should I be using a line feed in my code.  (this is what I am using now)
>>>          <xsl:text>&#xA;</xsl:text>
>>> Or should I be using a carriage return in my code.
>>>  <xsl:text>&#xD;</xsl:text>
>>> _____________________________________________________________________
>>> Catherine Wilbur  |  Senior Application Programmer  |  IT Services
>>> 401 Sunset Avenue, Windsor ON Canada  N9B 3P4
>>> (T) 519.253.3000 Ext. 2745  |  (F) 519.973.7083  |  (E)
>>> cwilbur@xxxxxxxxxxx
>>>  XSL-List info and archive <>
>>> EasyUnsubscribe <-list/528976> (by
>>> email <>)

Current Thread