[Fwd: [ALA-WO:896] Action Alert: Database Protection Legislation Needs ImmediateGrassroots Action]

["Olga Francois" <ofrancois@xxxxxxxx>]

ALAWON: American Library Association Washington Office Newsline
Volume 13, Number 9
February 19, 2004

In This Issue: ACTION  ALERT: Database Protection Legislation needs
immediate grassroots action!

H.R. 3261, the Database and Collections of Information
Misappropriations Act, has the support of House leadership and is
gaining momentum. On February 12, the House Judiciary Committee reported
out the bill with amendments and referred it to the House Energy and
Commerce Committee.  Energy and Commerce Committee has until March 12,
2004 to act on the bill. See the bill at www.thomas.loc.gov  

It is crucial that library advocates with Representatives sitting on
the House Energy and Commerce Committee tell their Representatives it is
time to oppose this legislation. 

H.R. 3261 would create what amounts to ownership rights in a wide
variety of data including facts.  Despite opposition from the libraries,
an array of business concerns including the U.S. Chamber of Commerce,
telecommunications, financial services and high technology
organizations, the House leadership has been committed to passing the
legislation. 

Talking Points
* Despite years of negotiation, H.R. 3261 is not acceptable to
libraries and other opponents.

* H.R. 3261 is simply not necessary. Existing laws are adequate to
protect the interests of the database producers, who have yet to prove
that their businesses have suffered because of any failure in the law. 

* H.R. 3261 gives broad protections to database producers and will lead
to reduced competition in the database market and increased costs to
libraries at a time when the cost of academic journals and access to
technical, scientific and medical information is already prohibitively
expensive for many libraries. 

* H.R. 3261 is too vague and will add to uncertainty in the law and
increase the likelihood of litigation. 

* The narrow exemption for nonprofit educational, scientific and
research institutions is inadequate because of the ambiguous language in
the bill. Also, the exemption could be overridden by terms in
"shrink-wrap" or non-negotiated contracts. 

* H.R. 3261 makes it permissible, in effect, to copyright facts - a
practice never allowed under copyright law.  By doing so, the bill could
give database producers both retroactive and perpetual rights to a wide
variety of information. 


These talking points are also available online with contact information
for your Representatives. Go  to ALA's Contact Congress legislative
action center. www.capwiz.com/ala.

E-Mail or fax the Representatives on the Energy and Commerce Committee
TODAY!

Members of the House Energy and Commerce Committee:

Arizona
John B. Shadegg 

California
Christopher Cox
George Radanovich
Mary Bono
Darrell Issa
Henry A. Waxman
Anna G. Eshoo
Lois Capps
Hilda L. Solis

Colorado
Diana DeGette

Florida
Michael Bilirakis
Cliff Stearns
Peter Deutsch
Jim Davis

Georgia
Nathan Deal 
Charlie Norwood

Idaho
C.L. "Butch" Otter

Illinois
John Shimkus
Bobby L. Rush
Jan Schakowsky

Indiana
Steve Buyer
 
Kentucky
Ed Whitfield 

Louisiana
W.J. "Billy" Tauzin,  Chairman
Christopher John 

Maine
Tom Allen 

Maryland
Albert R. Wynn 

Missouri
Karen McCarthy 

Massachusetts
Edward J. Markey

Michigan
Fred Upton
Mike Rogers
John D. Dingell, Ranking Member 
Bart Stupak

Mississippi
Charles "Chip" Pickering 

Missouri
Karen McCarthy

Nebraska
Lee Terry 

New Hampshire
Charles F. Bass 

New Jersey
Mike Ferguson 
Frank Pallone Jr.

New Mexico
Heather Wilson 

New York
Vito Fossella 
Edolphus Towns
Eliot L. Engel

North Carolina
Richard Burr,Vice Chairman 

Ohio
Paul E. Gillmor 
Sherrod Brown

Oklahoma
John Sullivan 

Oregon
Greg Walden 

Pennsylvania
James C. Greenwood 
Joseph R. Pitts
Michael F. Doyle

Tennessee
Bart Gordon

Texas
Ralph M. Hall
Joe Barton
Gene Green
Charles A. Gonzalez

Virginia
Rick Boucher
 
Wyoming	
Barbara Cubin