Subject: RE: [xsl] XSLT 1.1 comments From: Joshua Allen <joshuaa@xxxxxxxxxxxxx> Date: Mon, 12 Feb 2001 20:51:42 -0800 |
FWIW, practically every case I see a user using XSLT with *:script, it is because what they really wanted was a way to do XPath from their favorite language, and they thought XSLT was the only way to programatically manipulate node-sets accessed via XPath. -----Original Message----- From: Scott_Boag@xxxxxxxxx Sent: Mon 2/12/2001 8:18 PM To: xsl-list@xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx Cc: Subject: Re: [xsl] XSLT 1.1 comments Uche Ogbuji <uche.ogbuji@xxxxxxxxxxxxxxx> wrote: > I don't understand this. Why can't they? Why can't processor implementors > band together to sort it out? Why change the XSLT spec? > > In fact, why can't XSLT implementors in Python, C++, VB, Perl, Java and other > languages work together on this? Do it. XSLT 1.1 is on hold for a bit while we get some architectual ramifications of the 2.0 design sorted out. If you do it based on 1.0, and the processor implementors band together in a way that the user community agrees on, believe me, we'll be *very* happy to do the deletions to the 1.1 draft. We didn't do this for the fun of it... it was from user requests. With my selfish corporate hat on and blinders on, it doesn't matter to me if Xalan's extensions are interoperable with other processors. But the user community, i.e. the xsl-list, the apache community, and our corporate customers, have asked for it. If you don't like the effort, make constructive suggestions, write a complete alternate proposal, or start an alternative effort. Also, I believe the XSL WG would be very happy to put together some conference calls among XSLT implementors to sort out concerns about language independence in 1.1. The thing about specifications for general usage is that no one viewpoint is correct. You might even find that some of your views are off-base. > Actually, I missed the fact that DOM has an appendix with a Java binding. > This is probably because at least they kept the Java-centricity strictly to > that appendix. XSLT 1.1 does not do so. It's supposed to be that way. You should point out where we missed. > Obvious choice is to form an OASIS TC Good luck. -scott XSL-List info and archive: http://www.mulberrytech.com/xsl/xsl-list <http://www.mulberrytech.com/xsl/xsl-list> begin 600 winmail.dat M>)\^(C8$`0:0"``$```````!``$``0>0!@`(````Y`0```````#H``$%@`,` M#@```-$'`@`,`!0`,P`J``$`6`$!"8`!`"$````P,44Y,S$V1#)#0S9!130S M.3A$-S%$.49%-$5&03<S-P!>!P$@@`,`#@```-$'`@`,`!0`,P`U``$`8P$! M#8`$``(````"``(``0.0!@#X%```.@```$``.0!70;VH>)7``1\`,4`!```` M#@```#0`-``P`#``-@`T```````#`!I``````!\`,$`!````#@```#0`-``P M`#``-@`T```````#`!E``````!\`20`!````.````%(`90`Z`"``6P!X`',` M;`!=`"``6`!3`$P`5``@`#$`+@`Q`"``8P!O`&T`;0!E`&X`=`!S````0`!. M`(#6BOASE<`!`@%;``$```!'`````````($K'Z2^HQ`9G6X`W0$/5`(````` M4V-O='1?0F]A9T!L;W1U<RYC;VT`4TU44`!38V]T=%]";V%G0&QO='5S+F-O M;0``'P!F``$````*````4P!-`%0`4```````'P!G``$````J````4P!C`&\` M=`!T`%\`0@!O`&$`9P!``&P`;P!T`'4`<P`N`&,`;P!M```````?`%H``0`` M`"H```!3`&,`;P!T`'0`7P!"`&\`80!G`$``;`!O`'0`=0!S`"X`8P!O`&T` M`````!\`,D`!````*@```%,`8P!O`'0`=`!?`$(`;P!A`&<`0`!L`&\`=`!U M`',`+@!C`&\`;0```````@%<``$````:````4TU44#I30T]45%]"3T%'0$Q/ M5%53+D-/30````,`'4```````@%>``$```!'`````````($K'Z2^HQ`9G6X` MW0$/5`(`````4V-O='1?0F]A9T!L;W1U<RYC;VT`4TU44`!38V]T=%]";V%G M0&QO='5S+F-O;0``'P!H``$````*````4P!-`%0`4```````'P!I``$````J M````4P!C`&\`=`!T`%\`0@!O`&$`9P!``&P`;P!T`'4`<P`N`&,`;P!M```` M```?`%T``0```"H```!3`&,`;P!T`'0`7P!"`&\`80!G`$``;`!O`'0`=0!S M`"X`8P!O`&T``````!\`,T`!````*@```%,`8P!O`'0`=`!?`$(`;P!A`&<` M0`!L`&\`=`!U`',`+@!C`&\`;0```````@%?``$````:````4TU44#I30T]4 M5%]"3T%'0$Q/5%53+D-/30````,`'D```````@%Q``$````;`````<"5=@AP MX10\-DF"2!ZTB<$TAII(2@``67),`!\`=``!````0````'@`<P!L`"T`;`!I M`',`=`!``&P`:0!S`'0`<P`N`&T`=0!L`&(`90!R`'(`>0!T`&4`8P!H`"X` M8P!O`&T````"`0D0`0```$@,``!$#```1B8``$Q:1G51KN]^`P`*`')C<&<Q M,C6",@-#:'1M;#$#,#\!`P'W"H`"I`/C`@!C:,$*P'-E=#`@!Q,"@/\0`P!0 M!%8(50>R$=4.40,!W1#7,@8`!L,1U3,$1A#9;Q+K$>,([PGW.QC/#C`U.Q'2 M#&!C`%`+"0%D,S:3$6`+I30@$`(J7`ZRO0&09Q3P"J,1XQWH-!3P`#PA1$]# M5%E0`$4@2%1-3"!0`%5"3$E#("(M("\O5S-#(8!$5")$()0S+C(A@$5.G"(^ M'NT>CR/!,3@?\&\@HB,/)!\FD#,=@"5P17Q!1"7-#O$F[REO)/0V00[P/$U% M5$$'L$$Q+&`](D<)\`20871%!;`B$M!/3E0BT%03+/`%X45X$/%N9V4]!E)V M$S$O00"0`B`@-B`N,"XT-"5`+C-.,R+^*L\E`S<W'_!4<$E43$4ESC!0!_!E M`#H@6WAS;%T@@%A33%0@,2X.\*T%H&T'@`(P<R1N-1_P_B\S7S&/)D4TH3>@ M*$\FGP4[=#418#Q"3T19H"!D:7(].Y!R.N#/.U,`(0,P/?%D;P#@/?'Y"K%< M<1BP/?$0\`,P/E6/$6`["QSQ/`]G.38?\'A$258^*0``0&<[*38&-$.?0+)& M5TE7+&0@<"U08W0-X`=`;'AY(&4O04@`1\`1,"",22`1,"[P82!U$3"W!<!) M4`N`9S5D`_!T0##\*CH$]$=`2F!+,`0@.8SU0=5B!9!A25%*0!$`!4!=2G!E M2``8T$?3=P!P=/\)@$YQ!"!),$Z`2``M<#V@^4^@6%`M8$`P`U)-LCW`^5!` M878%L$I@+O!+KT("ZPM@+M!U.[!E1T``<$[0]TW#2G`(8&<.L$GU3P%-P5X@ M`B!.4T]S1V!O"<!A[P#`1Z8#@04@=0M@46]!U9IN!'$M$3%/$6-C!Y#;$3!. MT'8',$_D+CLI`<#?/C<*HCXW"G$D?#`H$2'@_T-K7)A`[T'_0P]$'T4O8SL% M.PLX'8`F;F)S</,"@#Y()V$!0&-_6W]<C_]=GUZO9<]@SV'?90]C_W#_:1V< M,30E448MT4C@:7!Z93TR<+L+XD!)+?5WPD\%$&<+@`=`!=!9\=]3,7?#="TL M$#U!4CXK"X"^90J!<Z]FICU0<+MB0$G:1@xxxx]\'^$O?8IM>1M7SV\C4P6@ M`D!?0F_5.[!`&&!T25`N-@%Y;_]Z?WN/?)]]KX=%!F`",']ONX!_@8=-+]$B MH`X@+P'0DC`.\#@Z)4%0382OGX6_AL^'WXCOD454;XJO+XN_@8],*S4A+9"P M<W2WA`"8T810;5=P3/!R2%#_3K`0\(1OCW^0CY&?DJ]`2?Q#8Y2/E9^6KYL/ MG!^=+^.>/XE^=6)J!9"*GZ%?_Z)H--B7/V\R-7^C#Z0?I2__KP^P'[$IJH]H MWVGO:O]L#_>U#Q[])5$O=5(Z[6[_<`;#(1`@,$M154\M\#VF,4C@='EL==`N M0$%2@$=)3BU224<@H/$T\#!P>"+Q/D@*L1`"_S]5/_,_L4!/LC<?X;+\PJ-_ MQ!^]/Q\JEP'(W7+`'_!0_W"_M(2PT!S2=#]U3W9?QT0&51#P+O!/9V)U:MII MI?\F.Y!G>3S'"!N`[4W0+E9`T2)``A`(<%05JYHRT7]GTIH^HEEW`V#_3K"I M++*OL[_1;]:_HG],*T_;OLH!2-`_$&XG!4!UWU.0+Y$!D%.3!``NV[]G/W%H M2B!7:$ABX1)-PC__XE_C;^1_Y83>7]]OX'16(7]9X@6PV+_9S]K<!W`+4&7_ M-C(%L*[/[=_:S]O?W._=]/YB4X-60!%`3=`%P$^1[*'W2U$%0`A@=.8OYS_H M3^F__^K/X&4NI54BK</Y,`60]_S_\6_R?_./])\!C_^?`*\$3_L"S]>+21+` M40!'D$=`37#_Y6:MP^_:2S`2P/L__$_@=!90F>!4(&Y'0$,K*ZE'0%9"1T!0 M%D!L1T#^2E$023!3@02?!:\&O(.`__;1$2\2/P:_!\\(W]X#4N;U3Q!W[+!K M]G@OT0R_#<__X'3B`O[_%7\6CQZ_'\\@VOY$3]!*8.)/^0_Z'*W'2W%[+]%4 M(&Q.T-3`4.!),&+[2T%-<&G`@$I`+O#VH?<Q__`@&[\<S^!E*_#0P%%11Y`] M4R!L(9\BKR"\5F%I9C]'L4>@**`H@3ZP52(R+O?'@.%P2;!G"D#W0D[!]\'7 M).\E__H<23ZP>=303[+_2T$J[RO_X'3V,%H2**$H,/XP4V,N+R\_(+Q5(NQ' M"ZS_]CP,@4\U38(WGSBO'>;^0.])4ZY2X5!*8'D[+SP_(+P_R:!.$!J!#W), M\""0979G_D#P(`JA92=6X$C1(!8J23"9T"HHP&%P</]/=E4B09]"K^!TX7#` M@#&DOU7Q52(H,44_1D\@O&168+YF,[\TS_H._D"_T&3I@N]+,RAQ*2(^(F;A M4#'R),'_5^`W7TQ_X#A!`%:Q?S%$1/E(4'%U>+"904]O4'\@O+I710!H25#[ M$#HP;#%@_G-?<(-PPS#LL#&0_D!!4OLHH>'"8B"1X7)(DUA?66_?X'3WD3<P M>+#I@FTQD-B`O_;S*K!<3UU?[OW&@%AX<//I<3^P97C8@#'0,;-C</?^0'A0 M9<%O_L`Q(&&0*@'_7U(4(V)?8V_KWN(_4[_Z#?Y",Z#ETF9?9V\@O$1<"J#\ M:2[4,#X3F(8*H#XB2K#_"G!+?VUO_2AV>.'"U-%@./=S'W0O(+QC1%#P4"JP MX9#O"J#]P$DQ.B!K,V$I(B3/_W"?-<\VU'C_>@]-Q>$#()#S@5`^$V5F*2$* MD660@5#_?3]^3W]=,<'#D-0`,:!),=YSU3`:<3&C"J%R+:%`T?_5@>_Q8+&% M;X9_+07)@)FP[FY@HNQ!8'!S:9`*H"DQ_^&A]V'I<(F?BJ]'79'5C2)_B-1< M/Y2_(*^8#YD?FBI!_FPJD`J@X-!(YH]/D%]#N.NMP>4P1QJA=2CQ2@%*0OU* MF'!RLO:6*I*:[YO_B[]^9F'@\##L<.5Q2=!JD6W]**!GGM^?[^!E"V_W!_?! M[XR"['"2`&J18O?!I)^EK_^:#!H6#''A</[`X6&H`@R/_ZGOX$<H,9??KT^9 M_[6_ML_]M]I4>,'B`:C1K?/^HS%9_RDB_?"WL#$@P_!$4+&33J%]05)N2Q`H MH)[/L\_@5G;]21!W8'!J\;B?N:_N_3^POV!!2%`*@('_@P_Z'%DW`?\Q0-5! M:?!),`I!8;%!-"J3_U>1A2$^X,(2:I2_G\"OM/3Y5Y!F+3H2M8_#K[>OSW]? MT(_1GQ?/&-_>(4$MTVS_=N'@T#%`[)`S85<3"G%!-/A$3TU*D6J10,%*P+(A M_&EXS#_-3UIF7U(0T!"C_RF`VO']X,]/TU_4;]\OX#__X4_5K]:_58&[D%:A M5J'L0?_V,&N0^Q!(X`L`1%%`T(@AWF5:X'+#^Q"!4'!8/]P_^T.:$*(M/I!K M`(Y`O,!%$'N3(>VQ=-A0X@_C'SU-;__NK^^_Y"_E/^9/56-!0]JV_\9/QU\G M#R@491+J7^MO#L7_OR!6,RJ0WO_RS_/?_U\`;_D!>DET:=&-8$K`DJ#8\O]+ M$$H!04-!`?@_^4_(;Z1`_P]@HC+"4ZT3_!_]+UIU%$'_*@/8M/\O`S\!3P[O M#_\1#^?U'_8O58%/8L(0KA#%L7\*0#%POH1+$"DA6T#:@4_005-)4[N`0Q'/ M$M^/$^\9[QK_'`E';V]``-<+3PQ?M/1LC/!K#K\=O\\;SR+_)`\E&BUS1*!E ML/\EWR;O)/\I;RI_*X\LGRVO_RZ_+\\PWS'O,O\T#S4?-B__-S\X3SE?.F\' M3PA?/;:K@?PM3'?QLI&]@&%#(`\A'^V197(7X(TA.CX_/T_Z:UE%/CQ!0Q15 MD&BGX&8$/2(6('1P.B\O:G=*D"Y[H&R>8,7P>>MJ(!?@+GMQ+W>A2])WTUXB M/'D[4,HP7]!D.U)F!PIP8;"3,'M(65!%P%),24Y+($H?2R]Y3#9]?4UA"G!A M\$+`7/!C9C%<HC`]$#VG3T]_4%]WQ!871I<[$%8O.PXY\C(\,"]!/'`[/SQ/ M/5\O6B];/UQ/758U7>$O1OA/3E1>.5:_7[!#(F(8KU\X0Q-?/T*&-UF"4%G> M`C!)`2]"3$]#2V!154]416%O98]G3U=!0S]K'T*S-3AH(D^\1%E9W5F`;)]O M(3=9D5!(5$U,7C!]<5`?`$<0`0```!X```!M`&4`<P!S`&$`9P!E`"\`<@!F M`&,`.``R`#(```````,`)@```````P`V```````#`-X_Z?T```,`\3\)!``` M`P#]/^0$```?`'```0```#````!;`'@`<P!L`%T`(`!8`%,`3`!4`"``,0`N M`#$`(`!C`&\`;0!M`&4`;@!T`',````+`/(0`0```!\`\Q`!````1````%(` M10`E`#,`00`@`%L`>`!S`&P`70`@`%@`4P!,`%0`(``Q`"X`,0`@`&,`;P!M M`&T`90!N`'0`<P`N`$4`30!,````"P#T$``````+`/40``````L`]A`````` M`@%'``$````P````8SU54SMA/4U#23MP/6US9G0[;#U2140M35-'+3`X+3`Q M,#(Q,S`T-3$T,EHM.3<``@'Y/P$```!1`````````-RG0,C`0A`:M+D(`"LO MX8(!`````````"]//4U)0U)/4T]&5"]/53U.3U)42$%-15))0T$O0TX]4D5# M25!)14Y44R]#3CTT-#`P-C0`````'P#X/P$````:````2@!O`',`:`!U`&$` M(`!!`&P`;`!E`&X``````!\`.$`!````#@```#0`-``P`#``-@`T```````" M`?L_`0```%$`````````W*=`R,!"$!JTN0@`*R_A@@$`````````+T\]34E# M4D]33T94+T]5/4Y/4E1(04U%4DE#02]#3CU214-)4$E%3E13+T-./30T,#`V M-``````?`/H_`0```!H```!*`&\`<P!H`'4`80`@`$$`;`!L`&4`;@`````` M'P`Y0`$````.````-``T`#``,``V`#0``````$``!S#3(SIN=Y7``4``"#`" M(@&O>)7``1\`&@`!````$@```$D`4`!-`"X`3@!/`%0`10``````'P`W``$` M```X````4@!%`#H`(`!;`'@`<P!L`%T`(`!8`%,`3`!4`"``,0`N`#$`(`!C M`&\`;0!M`&4`;@!T`',````?`#T``0````H```!2`$4`.@`@```````?`!T. M`0```#````!;`'@`<P!L`%T`(`!8`%,`3`!4`"``,0`N`#$`(`!C`&\`;0!M M`&4`;@!T`',````?`#40`0```)X````\`#0`1@`T`#$`.``R`$,`-P`Q`$,` M,0!&`$0`1``T`$(`00`P`#D`,P`W`$$`-P!%`$(`-P!"`#@`0@`T`$,`,0!$ M`#$`-0`V`#4`-`!``'(`90!D`"T`;0!S`&<`+0`P`#@`+@!R`&4`9`!M`&\` M;@!D`"X`8P!O`'(`<``N`&T`:0!C`'(`;P!S`&\`9@!T`"X`8P!O`&T`/@`` M````"P`I```````+`",```````,`!A!EL6QW`P`'$/(&```#`!`0``````,` M$1`!````'@`($`$```!E````1E=)5RQ04D%#5$E#04Q,645615)90T%314E3 M145!55-%4E5324Y'6%-,5%=)5$@J.E-#4DE05"Q)5$E30D5#055315=(0514 M2$594D5!3$Q95T%.5$5$5T%305=!651/1$]84``````"`7\``0```$\````\ M-$8T,3@R0S<Q0S%&1$0T0D$P.3,W03=%0C=".$(T0S%$,34V-31`<F5D+6US D9RTP."YR961M;VYD+F-O<G`N;6EC<F]S;V9T+F-O;3X``&?. ` end XSL-List info and archive: http://www.mulberrytech.com/xsl/xsl-list
Current Thread |
---|
|
<- Previous | Index | Next -> |
---|---|---|
Re: [xsl] XSLT 1.1 comments, Scott_Boag | Thread | Re: [xsl] XSLT 1.1 comments, Uche Ogbuji |
Re: [xsl] XSLT 1.1 comments, Scott_Boag | Date | Re: [xsl] XSLT 1.1 comments, Uche Ogbuji |
Month |