Subject: Indexing hypertext From: Norman Walsh <norm@xxxxxxxxxxxxx> Date: Mon, 4 Aug 1997 07:39:06 -0400 |
christo@xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx (Frank Christoph) writes: > I would say that the notion of "page numbers" itself is the > limitation, part of the legacy of an age when the only way to > reference parts of a document was by numbering pages. A Personally, I think linear documents are just fine. That's the way that it seems natural to write and read. (I suppose that's because I've been doing it that way since I was six or something, but it works for me). Anyway, I have a different topic in mind. When a printed document is indexed, page numbers are suitable references into the document (if a bit coarse). And actually, the page numbers convey more meaning that just reference points. If you're familiar with a book, you may know what's around page 150 so you can tell that 153 is probably the reference you're after. Similarly, given page numbers "3, 5, 19, 25-34, 67, 128" you can tell at a glance that the meaty discussion is probably at 25-34. When a document is placed online, how should the index be represented (or should the traditional index be replaced by something else)? I've tried three ways, none of which is ideal: 1. Use the page numbers from the printed book. It's a bit odd for the online reader. It requires that the document _have_ page numbers from a printed edition, and that you can extract them. On the plus side, you get the positive features of the print index. 2. Use other marks (dots, asterisks, sequential numbers or letters). The marks have no relationship to one another so, while it works, it has none of the advantages of the print index. 3. Use the title of the closest surrounding section. It's even coarser than page numbers (if the sections are long), but it may help you figure out where to go first. For the books that O'Reilly published online while I was there, I used option 3. Is there a better way? --norm DSSSList info and archive: http://www.mulberrytech.com/dsssl/dssslist
Current Thread |
---|
|
<- Previous | Index | Next -> |
---|---|---|
Re: Paragraph breaks, Frank Christoph | Thread | Re: Indexing hypertext, Paul Prescod |
Re: rtf backend/graphic scaling, Sebastian Rahtz | Date | Re: rtf backend/graphic scaling, Norman Walsh |
Month |